The Oldie's American correspondent, James Fletcher, discusses the closest election for years with Frank Luntz, America's top pollster
In 1997, you knew it would be Blair. In 2024, Starmer had it in the bag. So did Hillary Clinton in 2016. Except she didn’t.
And now, in 2024, all anybody knows about the outcome of the election in America is basically nothing, because all indicators are within the margin of error, no political rule applies to Trump, and Harris has a slow puncture after a promising start.
It’s easy to overlook one small detail – the one where the race started with Trump against Biden, who imploded with his diabolical debate performance that exposed the extent of his decline. A mad panic and time crunch resulted in Vice President Harris being parachuted in as the Democrats’ presidential candidate – without winning a primary – and with 100 days till the election.
In my opinion, Biden made two critical blunders: 1. Recklessly contesting the presidency for a second time, having heavily hinted he would only run once; 2. Exiting the race but staying in office. Had he resigned on health grounds, Harris would have been running as an incumbent.
Pollster Frank Luntz has identified two issues which voters care about above all others: affordability and immigration. Many economists have it that people are better off today than under the Trump presidency, but speak to many Americans and they disagree. Food has rocketed in cost as has petrol. Housing is close behind. The three areas of highest expenditure for the average voter. A man in rural Georgia told me he can no longer afford eggs – up 40% this year alone – often cited as the prime example of food inflation.
Harris was an early casualty in the 2019 primary process. And despite hitting Joe Biden hard with an attack on racial lines, and a resulting personal enmity with Mrs Biden, she was offered her place on the ticket at the last available opportunity. She has consistently polled badly as Vice President, and when concerns first arose about President Biden’s health and discussion about a potential successor ignited, Harris’s name was rarely mentioned – she was assumed to be complicit in the Biden health misrepresentation, and generally lightweight. Instead you heard about governors such as Gavin Newsom or Gretchen Whitmer. Critical endorsements for the Harris campaign were often late and lukewarm. When it finally came from the Obamas, it was a staged phone call, oddly tone-deaf, recorded for social media.
Trump by contrast and, by all conventional wisdom and logic, should have been taking on water, irreparably damaged by a litany of legal woes involving sexual misconduct, financial impropriety, and electoral meddling. And yet, just as he managed when the recording of the Access Hollywood bus emerged in October 2015, he has succeeded in playing this to his advantage, this time by portraying himself as a victim. Put simply, the message is: this legal injustice could happen to you too and I am your champion. America loves an outcast, pointing two fingers at the system. And it’s working. And it’s really hard for an opponent to tackle. And there is no precedent or playbook to refer to. Trump is the master of asymmetrical political warfare.
The Democrats launched Harris officially at their convention in Chicago. Obamas, Clintons and other endorsements from famous names dutifully added their voices. The mood was euphoric and the political calculus shifted, suggesting a restart of the race. Trump appeared to have been knocked off balance, and his pick of JD Vance suddenly seemed off key. There was talk of seasoned Democrat campaign handlers returning to the fray, and genuine possibility that a laser-targeted 100 day campaign could shunt Trump out of the spotlight and propel Harris to The White House. Money and endorsements piled in from the multimillionaire celebrity class, and Harris was vaunted as the great hope that the country was crying out for.
To be fair, going from pretty much minding your own business to presidential candidate is a big big deal. You need policy of your own, and fast. And you have no time to stress-test ideas in private. Mistakes will be public and embarrassing. You’re a sort of incumbent but you have to distance yourself from the President. You’re out of practice as a debater. Are you match-fit for a hostile interview? And when the euphoria subsides, can all this be aced in 100 days?
And with the answers to these questions in doubt, in the early days, Harris was shielded from the press. Interviews were done solely with friendly outlets. The nervous laugh was coached out. Her first interview was done with her VP pick Tim Walz chaperoning her in an empty cafe. It was odd, to put it mildly, and 100 days does not allow time for a single slip-up. She struggled to say what she would do as president on day one – the easiest and most predictable question possible. Her main challenge was the debate with Trump and she was widely believed to have succeeded. Both sides always say their person won. Success is defined by not crashing and burning. Trump’s performance was deemed to be poor, but he didn’t self-immolate, as Biden did. And Sarah Palin famously did, some years prior. Harris was well-prepared, cool and credible, which meant more money from the donors.
At rallies, Trump ‘spontaneously’ calls a union rep up to the stage, the same union rep, with 2-3 sentences ready – “I love this guy… we all need to go home and make sure we all vote for him. And our friends too”. Elon Musk is a born-again Trumper and has appeared at a Trump rally. He owns X/Twitter and has 202m followers on that platform, so a pro-Trump tweet hits millions of people in a second. For all that Musk too is an acquired taste, he wields enormous power on Trump’s behalf.
While Trump may never have read a presidential biography, or the Bible (his favourite book)... he is cunning and at peace with recreational fibbing and insults. He just can’t help hurling cheap invective, which women voters especially feel repulsed by. His lack of civility and decency only magnifies his total absence of discipline and message. At a rally last week, he referred to Harris as a ‘sh** Vice president’ followed by commentary on golfer Arnold Palmer’s anatomical advantage. Frank Luntz told me, “If Trump would just shut up, he’d win. But he can’t help himself”. The biggest threat to Trump, paradoxically, is Trump himself. And his mouth.
Harris has raised eye-watering sums of money, and the irony is that it’s almost impossible to spend urgently for various reasons: political financial records have to be immaculate, the banking system in America is still paper-based, and last-minute availability of airtime is hard to find. At a Harris rally this weekend, I was struck by the total lack of branded merchandise on sale. And maybe 20% of attendees had Harris tshirt or cap. It’s a small detail, but it’s a real miscalculation by her campaign. Obama sold tonnes. At a Trump rally (pictured), there is a vendor on every corner with a stall, others work the queues with a credit card machine at the ready, and so 90% of attendees are clad in red merchandise. The message and optics conveyed by a crowd united with the same colour are irrefutable.
Early voting (with shorter queues) has opened in many states, which also means there is time to handle any bureaucratic irregularities a voter may face. On a single voting day this probably results in no vote. So the early opening was the beginning of the end of the campaign. But with just under two weeks to go, both candidates are jamming in rallies and media appearances. The Harris team are making her more available, and the value in ramping up her appearances is that any mistakes evaporate more easily. The value is in going off-piste, taking a risk, reaching for audiences that may be harbouring undecided voters. A town hall on CNN yesterday devoured a lot of time and arguably offered little reward. Trump is appearing on the Joe Rogan podcast this week, whose Elon Musk episode attracted 60m listeners. Word is Rogan is sympathetic to Trump. Cable news rarely has more than 1m viewers. Last night’s CNN Town Hall had 100,000 viewers according to Nielsen.
I’m looking closely at the language. Harris has shifted from the ‘joy vibe’ and has adopted a more attacking posture towards Trump, calling him a fascist on CNN yesterday. Today’s New York Times dismisses this tactic because the word is tired and its meaning diminished. It was regularly pinned to George W Bush and it impugns Trump voters. It skirts close to Clinton’s ‘basket of deplorables’. As Frank Luntz observed, “Harris hasn’t yet told us who she is or what she believes in… and her campaign seems to be in danger of making similar mistakes to Hillary Clinton”. He’s worried for her. Trump-bashing introduces the additional risk of keeping him front and centre. A Trump voter either loves him, or thinks he’s an appalling human but believes he’s better for the economy / immigration / Supreme Court / pro life lobby – and will therefore vote for him. Attack lines, therefore, make little tactical sense for the Democrats, which should be proactively selling themselves in.
It’s also impossible to exaggerate the flagrant imbalance of US media. There is no pretence or requirement for television news to offer any balance. The same story on hard-right Fox and hard-left MSNBC is sentient parody. Take the summarising of the presidential debate for example. Harris was the hands-down winner, according to MSNBC, and Trump the victor in the eyes of Fox. The point is – an undecided voter has little by way of resources on mainstream media to form a view. Of course there is information online, but with the proliferation of televisions and radios blaring out their weighted noise in airports, restaurants, lifts, taxis etc, its subliminal effect on critical thinking is profound. And it forces the choice facing the country to be prosecuted at shallow depth. In the vacuum, seconds-long clips on social media offer equal bias and distortion, as the alternative to serious thoughtful debate. As West Wing writer Aaron Sorkin said, “The moment we, the voters, insist on a higher level of debate… that's when we'll get one”.
Put crudely, an election is a marketing competition which favours the candidate that can tell and sell their story most convincingly to the electorate. American voters are choosing between what Democrat candidate Bobby Jones in Georgia identifies as “the two most powerful drugs in the human psyche: nostalgia and retribution”, and what Harris calls “Turning the page”. She just has to get urgent and serious about telling voters what exactly they’ll find over that page.
Who’s going to win? I have no idea - even now.
Enjoy The Oldie every month. Subscribe to The Oldie.









