The indecently perfect symmetry of human existence has been well-documented ever since Genesis (the Old Testament page-turner, not the band – even Phil Collins has his limitations) observed, ‘for you are dust, and to dust you will return’.
Shakespeare’s Seven Ages of Man poem, from As You Like It, caught the mood. ‘Last scene of all/ That ends this strange eventful history/ Is second childishness and
mere oblivion/ Sans teeth, sans eyes, sans taste, sans everything.’
Yet, for all the exploration of the subject, one question is widely ignored. In the context of abortion, there is endless, feverish discussion about exactly when – conception/ foetal heartbeat/ at a certain number of weeks? – life can be said to begin.
But we too seldom talk about when it is effectively over. When, to be more precise, does it become folly to try to extend a life that has plainly run its course?
It is a question with which many of us will have to deal, as patients or as carers, and one that has continually preyed on me since my father’s final days.
In August 2021 came an episode of such tragicomic synchronicity as to have the most devout wondering what kind of talentless celestial quarterwit is writing the script.
At around 7pm one Saturday, my dad expressed his gift for laconically combining stoicism, courtesy and understatement in a single sentence.
‘Chap,’ he murmured from the recliner chair that had become his whole world, ‘I hate to bother you, but I have a slightly alarming pain in my heart.’

Within seconds of hearing that – four or five at the outside – I heard a loud gushing noise from upstairs. ‘Sorry, Bronze,’ I said, using his family nickname, ‘could you give me a moment?’
‘Of course, chap,’ he said. ‘No rush.’
It was the most resolutely English conversational exchange of my life.
I nipped up a flight to find a torrent of water cascading through the dining-room ceiling. Way too crude and lousy a scriptwriter, this deity, I thought – even for EastEnders. I stood there paralysed by uncertainty as to which of the two crises to attend to first, before a chilling clarity descended. Whatever the running order of emergency action, the one thing it would not include was calling 999. My dad was far too close to death for that. No intervention could usefully extend his life now.
If a blue-light ambulance came, the paramedics would want to take him to hospital.
Despite having lasting power of attorney (LPA), I might well be unable to dissuade them. I would not betray his trust by allowing him to die alone and unvisited, in those hateful days of Covid, and terrified on a ward.
He had already endured three weeks of unimaginable torment in hospital earlier that summer. Fit for discharge after the first, he was lost in that brutal NHS bureaucratic vortex for the following two.
When his mobile slipped down the bed, he had to go on hunger strike for two days before any of the nursing staff bothered to find it.
So, whatever the medical advice, however insistent, however threatening, I would ensure that he died at home as he wanted.
I put a bucket under the leak, and went back down to my dad. Even as I fed him a 300 mg aspirin, I falsely reassured him that it was indigestion.
The following Monday morning, we went by elective ambulance to the Macmillan Cancer Centre attached to University College Hospital for his fortnightly blood transfusion. He was so weak and frail that he had to be transported to and from the ambulance by stretcher. It was as excruciating for him as it was transparently futile.
But he wanted to go and I didn’t have the heart, or the guts, to prevent it. Just as some eight months earlier, I hadn’t had the heart, or more accurately the courage, to try to talk him out of the chemotherapy that may or may not have extended his life by a couple of months – but cost him his balance, mobility, comfort and every ounce of quality of life. That I will always regret.
When we arrived, I took a very sweet, very young doctor in a hijab to one side, and mentioned the cardiac pain. She performed an ECG, and reciprocally took me to one side. ‘He’s had a pretty major heart attack,’ she said. ‘I’ve called cardiology. We’ll have him taken over to have stents inserted.’
The reflex question that very nearly escaped my lips was ‘Are you completely fucking nuts?’ Narrowly stifling it, I said, ‘Look at him, doctor. For God’s sake, just look at him. How many days do you think he has left? What possible benefit can there be in an invasive procedure that will mean he has to stay, and more than likely die, in hospital?’
Then I started sobbing uncontrollably, in a way I hadn’t since childhood. The prospect of a battle to stop this lunacy had pierced the thin veneer of self-control.
I apologised to the doctor, citing sleeplessness, and begged her to check his notes. ‘You’ll see he wants to die at home,’ I said, ‘and I won’t allow anything that risks that.’ Half an hour later, she returned. She’d read the notes and talked to his consultant, and now agreed that such an intervention was inadvisable. I burst into tears again, this time of relief and gratitude.
That doctor was no doubt outstanding at her work (no one who isn’t gets to work at Macmillan), and eager only to help. And, in spite of that, or because of it, she was overlooking her Hippocratic Oath (‘First, do no harm’), and needed forcibly talking out of a monstrous mistake by a deranged man with tears flowing down his face like the leak through the dining-room ceiling.
All over the country today, every day, hundreds of people, thousands upon thousands of us, will be victims of this monumental error of medical judgement.
The very elderly and very sick are routinely robbed of the deaths they desire by that wholly understandable medical urge to do something, anything, rather than nothing.
Nothing was done. Six days later, my dad died as he had wished, serenely in his chair.
Almost two years later, my mother had become a prisoner of her own recliner, robbed of mobility by the dramatically-broken ankle she was too frail to have surgically fixed.
Her mind until almost the very end was as sharp as my dad’s had been until his. She remained reliably hilarious until her final days.
‘Now then, Suzanne,’ asked a nurse, running through the routine dementia/ urinary-tract-infection questions with which we’d both become so fatigued, ‘can you tell me where we are?’
My mother flashed me her trademark sardonic glance, lips a touch pursed, eyebrows minimally raised, and snapped back, ‘New Zealand.’
The nurse momentarily looked alarmed, then guffawed.
But however vibrantly healthy my mother’s sarcastic wit, her body was wrecked beyond repair. A few days after, she took a terminal turn. Despite multiple courses of antibiotics, she was too weak to fight off a chest infection.
One Wednesday in late July, with a carer filling in for me, I went for a couple of stress-busting hours to the steam room at the Turkish baths, almost the last place on earth these days where one is entirely out of contact. I returned to my locker to find a dozen missed calls on the iPhone screen.

A district nurse, making the tri-weekly visit to dress her sores, had found her so unresponsive that she called an ambulance.
I rushed back to find two paramedics in attendance. One, a forceful young man, said they were going to take her to the Royal Free Hospital a few minutes’ drive away. I told him that they would not. That my mother was visibly in her last days, if not hours; that it was too late for intravenous broad-spectrum antibiotics to do more than briefly prolong her life – for no purpose; that she’d be traumatised by the transit; that even if she survived it, she would almost certainly die alone and scared, if she was conscious of her whereabouts, in a strange place.
I added with wonted pomposity that, while of course I appreciated what they were trying to do for her, allowing them to take her would be an unforgivable act of moral cowardice.
Fearful of the consequences of agreeing, naturally eager to cover himself, the paramedic rang my mother’s GP and put her on speakerphone. She too wanted my mother in hospital. Again, l resisted.
For two hours, over multiple calls with the GP, the three of us argued. Eventually, the paramedic stood over my mother with his clipboard. He would write in his report, he said, that I had kept her from hospital expressly against medical advice.
I reiterated that she was too close to death to be moved; that attempting to transport her down four flights in the stairlift (the only plausible way) would at the very least break limbs.
He pondered this nervously – and changed his mind. He would recommend palliative care in
his report instead. My mother died, peacefully, some dozen hours later.
The GP, a highly experienced and excellent physician, rang that afternoon, and spoke the last words you expect to hear from a doctor.
‘I was wrong,’ she said. ‘You were absolutely right.’
Full-time carers, knowing the patient’s state of health so much more intimately than even the best professionals, almost invariably will be right. Not all will have LPA, however, or if they do they may lack the stubbornness to resist concerted pressure.
Time and time again, from friends who have been through the experience with parents, from nurses who see it all the time, from a rabbi too well- acquainted with the syndrome from visiting his flock, I’ve heard the identical story with a different outcome.
It is a wretched, heart-rending tale of the medical craving to do something – leading to additional pain and distress, and a lonely, petrified hospital death unleavened by the comfort of family or friends.
Modern medicine is startlingly adept at keeping people alive, as we know, and staggeringly poor at knowing when to let them go. We are, as in so many areas, decades behind the Dutch and Scandinavians.
This is not a plea for euthanasia, though in a country less dominated by the trenchant moralists of the right-wing media there would be intense debate about that.
Once upon a time, a private GP told me, fancy doctors like him would administer the Brompton cocktail (equal parts brandy and morphine) to those whose brief remaining span would be filled only with an agonising struggle to breathe through drowning lungs. The patient would float merrily away.
Dr Harold Shipman did for that practice along with his untold hundreds of victims. Recalling him, one needs to be exceedingly cautious about sanctioning anyone to play God.
Yet playing God is what we are obliged to do, as I was, by preventing aggressive treatment that robs the dying of a decent death for no discernible purpose other than to assuage that medical compulsion to act.
So when is it that a life, though the heart still beats and the pupils react to light, is effectively over? If it isn’t an easy question to pose, it is an infinitely harder one to answer. Amorphously straddling the borderline between medicine and philosophy, it defies the rigid protocols that govern almost every other area of medicine.
But if caring for my parents taught me anything, it is this. You may not be able to define it, as a US Supreme Court Justice almost said of pornography, but you know it when you see it.
You recognise that point in the fading embers of a human life when delaying death is an act not of kindness, but of inadvertent cruelty.
That gruesome moment when insisting on inaction in defiance of medical advice becomes the truest and final expression of love.
Enjoy The Oldie every month. Subscribe to The Oldie.

















