"The Oldie is an incredible magazine - perhaps the best magazine in the world right now" Graydon Carter, founder of Air Mail and former Editor of Vanity Fair

The lost chance to halt Lenin - Harry Cluff

Blog | By Harry Cluff | Jun 29, 2024

Allen Dulles by Cecil Stoughton

Allen Dulles (1893-1969) is to date the longest serving Director of the CIA as well as being its first civilian chief. He oversaw coup d’etats in Guatemala and Iran and was responsible for the disastrous Bay of Pigs invasion, for which he was summarily sacked by JFK. After Kennedy’s death, he joined the Warren Commission and played a pivotal role in its investigation of the President’s assassination. His legacy still looms large in the intelligence world. An insatiable womaniser gifted with a commodious mind, Dulles was in many ways the perfect American spy. However, as with fledglings, in his early professional life, he made some unforgettable blunders.

In April, 1917, Dulles was working for the State Department in their office in Bern. It was a pretty dull posting for an energetic, convivial freshman diplomat, but he managed to make something of it (mostly by chasing beautiful girls, talent-spotting potential agents and playing sports of every sort). On the afternoon of Friday 8th April, he was just leaving his office to play tennis with the latest object of his desires when the telephone rang. He reluctantly walked back from the door, slung his racket and shoes over his shoulder and picked up the receiver. ‘Dulles’ he said. A State Department operator informed him that a mysterious Russian emigre was trying to reach him urgently. Dulles grumbled before telling the operator to put the Russian through. On the other end of the line a gruff, severe Russian voice answered. ‘Hello. My name is Vladimir Illyich Ulyanov. I must meet you tonight to discuss an urgent matter.’. Dulles had plans that night (he probably hoped his tennis match would evolve into something equally enervating but doubly enjoyable). ‘I can’t tonight,’ replied Dulles, ‘come and see me on Monday.’. ‘That’ll not be possible’ retorted the Russian before abruptly hanging up.

The next day, Ulyanov boarded a sealed train that trundled out of Switzerland, through Germany into Russia via Finland. When he arrived in St Petersburg five days later, he was greeted by crowds of enthusiastic workers waving billowing red banners stitched with Bolshevik slogans. They chanted Ulyanov’s famous sobriquet ‘Lenin! Lenin!’ and excitedly carried the revolutionary leader out of the station and into annals of Russian history.

Dulles never divulged if his rendezvous that April night in Bern was worth him missing the opportunity of a lifetime - to engage with and potentially recruit the future head of the Russian State. Later in his career, Dulles was asked to lecture new recruits to the CIA. He brought up the missed opportunity everytime he stood in front of an audience. The moral of the tale, he would say, is never miss a meeting or not pick up the phone. The chance of a lifetime might be on the end of the line.

Enjoy The Oldie every month. Subscribe to The Oldie.